Counselor, Felony Alternative to Incarceration

CounselorFull-Time

Listed compensation

$60.5K - $78.8K

The week · per this posting

Ask the employer about call expectations, weekend coverage, nights and shift pattern and time off.

Posted 3mo ago

Job Description

The Organization

The Center for Justice Innovation is a nonprofit organization dedicated to advancing community safety and racial justice. Since 1996, we’ve worked alongside communities, courts, and those most directly affected by the justice system to build stronger, healthier, and more equitable neighborhoods. With a team of over 900 staff and an annual budget of $130 million, the Center carries out its mission through three core strategies:

  • Operating Programs that pilot new ideas and address local challenges;
  • Conducting original research to evaluate what works—and what doesn’t; and
  • Providing expert assistance and policy guidance to reformers across the country and beyond.
  • Backed by decades of on-the-ground experience and nationally recognized expertise, we bring innovative, practical, and lasting solutions to justice systems nationwide.
  • Learn more about our work at www.innovatingjustice.org.

The Opportunity

The Center for Justice Innovation is seeking a Counselor to join a team of staff—including social workers, case managers, and a peer navigator—who work with defendants participating in the Manhattan Felony Alternative to Incarceration (ATI) Court.

The Felony ATI Court, which is led by Administrative Judge Ellen Biben, seeks to forge a new response to individuals charged with felonies by linking them to community-based social services.

The Court is the first of its kind, providing an innovative model for other jurisdictions seeking to develop and implement meaningful post-conviction sentencing options for individuals facing felony charges.

Reporting to the Clinical Director of Felony ATI, the Counselor will be part of a team that provides neutral, third-party assessments and case management services to the Felony Alternative to Incarceration (ATI) Court. The Counselor will be responsible for conducting independent clinical assessments, providing referrals to community-based services, offering comprehensive clinical case management, and monitoring participant compliance.

An essential and dynamic feature of the Counselor ’s role will be close collaboration with key stakeholders.

The Counselor will work regularly with the judge and court staff from New York Country Supreme Court who oversee the Felony ATI Court, as well as with other stakeholders, including the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office and New York City defense organizations.

Court-based work is an exciting, unique and demanding area of practice, and the Counselor role involves navigating and constructively engaging with differing and, at times, competing stakeholder perspectives.

Responsibilities Include But Are Not Limited To

Conduct detailed risk-need profiles and clinical assessments for potential Felony ATI Court participants;

Develop treatment recommendations for services for potential Felony ATI participants to court stakeholders (judge, defense counsel, prosecutor and court staff);

Provide comprehensive, clinically-informed case management services to a caseload of pre-plea and court-mandated Felony ATI participants to help address issues such as substance use, mental health issues, trauma, domestic violence, housing and vocational needs, and other challenges in a participant’s life (e. g. new arrests, family court cases and other civil legal issues);

  • Make appropriate community-based referrals for a variety of social service needs;
  • Manage and monitor compliance with treatment mandates, including care coordination with providers;
  • Provide written treatment updates for court stakeholders for all court-involved participants;
  • Participate in regular interdisciplinary case conferences with court stakeholders;

Coordinate with court stakeholders on any non-compliance issues and assist clients in getting back into compliance, including re-engaging clients, arranging return on warrants, and implementing graduated responses to encourage future compliance;

Facilitate and help to develop and/or revise curricula for a range of on-site psychoeducational groups and individual case management sessions;

Attend court on calendar days, as needed, to help clients navigate court and collaborate with court staff and stakeholders;

Collaborate and maintain strong relationships with key stakeholders, including the resource coordinator, prosecutors, defense attorneys, and other court and programmatic staff;

  • Assist with toxicology testing and reporting, as needed;
  • Provide crisis intervention and de-escalation, as needed;
  • Provide voluntary referrals to community-based services, as needed;
  • Establish and maintain linkages with community partners who can support program work;

Assist the Clinical Director with the development and implementation of new initiatives; including best clinical practices, and appropriate evidence-based interventions;

Enter and maintain appropriate up-to-date participant information, including assessment, case management, and case outcome data;

  • Provide clinical services as described above to program participants on a voluntary basis post-mandate;
  • Participate in clinical group supervision, staff meetings, and trainings, as scheduled;
  • Attend evening community-based meetings and events, as needed; and;

Assist with other programmatic and administrative tasks to support the Felony ATI Court’s activities, as needed.

Qualifications

MHC, with a minimum of 3-4 years in criminal justice and/or related fields, such as healthcare, substance use and mental health treatment, homelessness and housing services, education, job training/workforce development, child welfare and family services, youth services, elder care services, domestic violence programming, sex offense treatment, and services for people with development disabilities, is required. Experience in a court or criminal justice settings, including working with incarcerated people, preferred;

  • Licensure as LMSW or LMHC is stronly preferred;
  • Experience using trauma-informed and strengths-based approaches and working with participants with substance use, mental health, or co-occurring needs, co-occurring disorders, preferred;
  • Experience working with and addressing the specific needs of young adults, LGBTQ+ people, and women preferred;
  • Knowledge and/or lived experience related to the criminal justice system and its impacts on communities;

Commitment to, and experience using, holistic and strengths-based approaches, meeting “participants where they are”, as well as the ability to work with people from diverse backgrounds in a culturally-competent manner;

Willingness and ability to work collaboratively with a variety of court personnel and on-site partner agencies in a high-pressure/fast paced work environment;

Skill and openness to constructive engagement with differing and, at times, competing stakeholder perspectives;

Excellent written and verbal communication skills, including the ability to provide succinct and comprehensive verbal updates about treatment engagement and compliance to legal stakeholders during court appearances and case conferences;

  • Excellent organization and time management skills; and;
  • Bilingual (English-Spanish) preferred.
  • Position Type: Full-time.
  • Position Location: Manhattan, NY.

Compensation: The compensation range for this position is $60,500 - $78,800 and is commensurate with experience.

Benefits: The Center for Justice Innovation offers an excellent benefits package including comprehensive healthcare with a national network, free basic dental coverage, vision insurance, short-term and long-term disability, life insurance, and flexible spending accounts including commuter FSA.

We prioritize mental health care for our staff and offer services like Talkspace and Ginger through our healthcare plans. We offer a 403(b) retirement plan with a two-to-one employer contribution up to 5%.

The Center for Justice Innovation is an equal opportunity employer committed to fostering an inclusive and diverse workplace.

We do not discriminate based on race, color, religion, gender identity, gender expression, pregnancy, national origin, age, military service eligibility, veteran status, sexual orientation, marital status, disability, or any other category protected by law.

We strongly encourage and welcome applications from women, people of color, members of the LGBTQ+ community, and individuals with prior contact with the criminal justice system. Our goal is to create a supportive and respectful environment where everyone, regardless of background or identity, feels valued and included.

At this time, the Center is unable to sponsor or take over sponsorship of an employment visa. All applicants must be legally authorized to work in the United States at the time of application and throughout the duration of employment.

Candidates are expected to provide accurate and truthful information throughout the hiring process. Any misrepresentation, falsification, or omission of material facts may result in disqualification from consideration, withdrawal of an offer, or termination of employment, regardless of when discovered.

In compliance with federal law, all hires must verify their identity and eligibility to work in the United States and complete the required employment verification form upon hire. Please refer to the job posting for relevant contact information. If contact details are not provided, we kindly ask that you refrain from inquiries via phone or email, as only shortlisted candidates will be contacted.

Key Responsibilities

The Counselor conducts clinical assessments and provides comprehensive case management for participants in the Manhattan Felony Alternative to Incarceration Court. They collaborate with judges, prosecutors, and defense counsel to monitor compliance and link individuals to community-based social services.

Qualifications

Education
Master's degree (postgraduate degree)
Experience
2+ years of experience

Key Skills

Clinical AssessmentTrauma-Informed CareStrengths-Based ApproachRisk-Need ProfilingPsychoeducational Group FacilitationInterdisciplinary CollaborationCultural CompetencyWritten CommunicationSpanish Bilingualism

Work-Life Balance Analysis

WeekdayDoc's proprietary algorithm rates Counselor, Felony Alternative to Incarceration at Center for Justice Innovation a 7.2 out of 10 for work-life balance — classified as very good. This places the position in the top 25% in Counseling — ranked against 579 active Counseling listings on WeekdayDoc.

Counselor Career Context

Of the 50 active Counselor listings this role was benchmarked against, 42% are remote, 40% have no call, 60% require no weekends.

Counselor pay on WeekdayDoc is down 3.3% vs. the prior quarter (through Aug 2026).

The cost-of-living index for New York is 107.9 (US average = 100; BEA Regional Price Parities (2024)), so the posted ~$70k midpoint carries the purchasing power of roughly $65k in an average-cost state. 64.6% of New York clinicians report burnout symptoms in WeekdayDoc's Burnout Index (2026-01 data).

Top Counselor Jobs

38 matches · ranked by pay

Salary Distribution38 jobs · 31 employers

16
<$85k
12
$85k-100k
5
$100k-115k
5
$115k-130k

Annual compensation range

Benefits & Perks31 jobs

401k / retirement match
84% this job
CME allowance
42%
Sign-on bonus
32%
Loan repayment
10% this job
PSLF eligible
6% this job

Share of similar jobs offering each benefit

#1

Licensed Professional Counselor (LPC)

Gotham Enterprises · Metairie, Louisiana

$115k-$120k
#2

Remote Mental Health Counselor (LMFT, LCSW, LMHC)

Gotham Enterprises · Watertown, New York

$115k-$120k
#3

NY Licensed DBT Therapist - DBT Master’s or Doctoral - Telehealth - Full-Time

$93k-$120k
#4

Licensed Mental Health Counselor

$90k-$115k
+ 36 more · ranked by pay

Work-life snapshot

median 6.4this job 7.2
Better work-life than 80% of Counseling listings

Listing-based score, 0–10, across 579 comparable listings. Shaded area = the share scoring below this one.

  • On-site

Living in New York

Typical 3-bedroom home value
$876k≈ 14.5× annual pay
Typical market rent
$4,154/mo≈ 82% of gross pay
Residents’ average commute
40 min
State income tax
Up to 10.9%
Sources & methodology

Sources: Zillow home values (Aug 2026), Zillow market rents (Aug 2026), U.S. Census ACS 2024 five-year.

Ratios use this listing’s gross annual pay. Not a cost-of-living guarantee.

Center for Justice Innovation logo

About Center for Justice Innovation

Non-profit Organizations
New York, New York
501-1,000 employees

Benefits & Perks

Comprehensive healthcare with national network
Free basic dental coverage
Vision insurance
Short-term and long-term disability
Life insurance
Flexible spending accounts including commuter FSA
Mental health care services (Talkspace, Ginger)
403(b) retirement plan with two-to-one employer contribution up to 5%