Managed Care Coordinator I (Behavioral Health)

Healthcare AdminFull-Time

Listed compensation

$45k-$60k

The week · per this posting · weekdays assumed

Ask the employer about the work setting, call expectations, weekend coverage and time off.

Posted 1h ago · Verified live

Job Description

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey empowers our members to achieve their best health. For over 90 years, we have been New Jersey’s health solutions leader driving innovations that improve health care quality, affordability, and member experience. Our members are our neighbors, our friends, and our families.

It is this understanding that drives us to better serve and care for the 3.5 million people who place their trust in us. We pride ourselves on our best-in-class employees and strive to maintain an innovative and inclusive environment that allows them to thrive. When our employees bring their best and succeed, the Company succeeds.

About the Role

This position supports the Clinical Operations functions and acts as a liaison between Members, Physicians, Delegates, Operational Business members and Member Service Coordinators

What You'll Do

Performs review of service requests for completeness of information, collection and transfer of non-clinical data, and acquisition of structured clinical data from physicians/patients.

Prepare, document and route cases in appropriate system for clinical review. Initiates call backs and correspondence to members and providers to coordinate and clarify benefits.

Upon completion of inquiries initiate call back or correspondence to Physicians/Members to coordinate/clarify case completion.

  • Reviewing professional medical/claim policy related issues or claims in pending status.
  • Acts as liaison with providers, members and Care Managers.
  • Perform other relevant tasks as assigned by Management.

Utilization Management

Upon collection of clinical and non-clinical information MCC can authorize services based upon scripts or algorithms used for pre-review screening.

Non Clinical staff members are not responsible for conducting any UM review activities that require interpretation of clinical information.

Handles initial screening for pre-certification requests from physicians/members via incoming calls or correspondence based on scripts and workflows, and under the oversight of clinical staff.

Case Management

Assists members with finding providers, resolving problems and answering questions regarding anything from how to obtain services to how to file an appeal.

Makes outbound calls to in order to engage members in Case Management and to complete the necessary health assessment(s) (IHS/HRA, CNA/CMNA, MLTSS Elig Survey*.)

Educates members regarding preventive health activities and services.

Assists member to make appointments with their PCP, specialists, and/or transportation, etc. Handle PCP, demographic changes and/or new ID cards as requested by members.

  • Triage and distribute referrals from Member Services and incoming faxes from providers.
  • Reviews medical, dental and vision claims and address gaps in member's preventative care.

Letters Team

Review medical and administrative documentation for accuracy, grammar, and compliance with regulatory standards.

  • Perform initial screening of determination letters, ensuring clarity and compliance before distribution.
  • Make sound, timely decisions under the direction and supervision of a designated Supervisor.

What You Bring

Education/Experience

  • High School Diploma/GED required.
  • Prefer 1-2 years customer service or medical support related position.

Knowledge and Skills

  • Requires knowledge of medical terminology, Preferred – Medicaid CM.
  • Requires Good Oral and Written Communication skills.
  • Requires ability to make sound decisions under the direction of Supervisor.
  • Prefer knowledge of contracts, enrollment, billing & claims coding/processing.
  • Prefer knowledge Managed Care principles.
  • Prefer the ability to analyze and resolve problems with minimal supervision.
  • Prefer the ability to use a personal computer and applicable software and systems.
  • Team Player, Strong Analytical, Interpersonal Skills.

Why Horizon?

At Horizon, you’ll do meaningful work that directly improves lives—while being supported by a mission‑driven organization that values expertise, collaboration, and growth. We believe that when our people thrive, our communities do too. If you are passionate about making an impact, we’d love to hear from you!

Salary Range

$44,600 - $59,745

This compensation range is specific to the job level and takes into account the wide range of factors that are considered in making compensation decisions, including but not limited to: education, experience, licensure, certifications, geographic location, and internal equity.

This range has been created in good faith based on information known to Horizon at the time of posting. Compensation decisions are dependent on the circumstances of each case. Horizon also provides a comprehensive compensation and benefits package which includes:

  • Comprehensive health benefits (Medical/Dental/Vision)
  • Retirement Plans
  • Generous PTO
  • Incentive Plans
  • Wellness Programs
  • Paid Volunteer Time Off
  • Tuition Reimbursement

Disclaimer

This job summary has been designed to indicate the general nature and level of work performed by colleagues within this classification. It is not designed to contain or be interpreted as a comprehensive inventory of all duties, responsibilities, and qualifications required of colleagues assigned to this job.

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey is an Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action employer.

All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity, protected veteran status or status as an individual with a disability and any other protected class as required by federal, state or local law.

Horizon will consider reasonable accommodation requests as part of the recruiting and hiring process.

Key Responsibilities

The Managed Care Coordinator acts as a liaison between members, providers, and clinical staff to facilitate service requests and coordinate care. They are responsible for reviewing medical documentation, managing case files, and assisting members with health assessments and appointment scheduling.

Requirements

Candidates must possess a High School Diploma or GED and have strong oral and written communication skills. Preferred qualifications include 1-2 years of experience in customer service or medical support and knowledge of medical terminology and managed care principles.

Key Skills

Analytical skillsProblem solvingData entryClaims processingRegulatory compliance

Healthcare Administration Career Context

Of the 40 active Healthcare Administration listings this role was benchmarked against, 13% are remote, 40% have no call, 63% require no weekends.

The cost-of-living index for New Jersey is 108.8 (US average = 100; BEA Regional Price Parities (2024)), so the posted ~$52k midpoint carries the purchasing power of roughly $48k in an average-cost state. 63.8% of New Jersey clinicians report burnout symptoms in WeekdayDoc's Burnout Index (2026-01 data).

Healthcare Administration pay on WeekdayDoc is down 6.9% vs. the prior quarter (through Sep 2026).

Top Healthcare Admin Jobs

21 matches · ranked by pay

Salary Distribution21 jobs · 18 employers

7
<$75k
5
$75k-85k
5
$85k-95k
2
$95k-105k
2
$105k+

Annual compensation range

Benefits & Perks18 jobs

401k / retirement match
100% this job
Loan repayment
11%
Sign-on bonus
6%
Relocation assistance
6%
PSLF eligible
6%

Share of similar jobs offering each benefit

#1

Behavioral Health Case Manager I - Western New York

Elevance Health · Wallingford, Connecticut

$64k-$116k
#2

Behavioral Health Case Manager

Confidential Employer · San Antonio, Texas

$75k-$112k
#3

Manager-Physician Practice I - Multispecialty Clinic

$32.58-$48.87/hr
#4

Utilization Review Clinician - Behavioral Health

$27.02-$48.55/hr
+ 19 more · ranked by pay

Work-life snapshot

median 3.9this job 1.5
Below most Healthcare Administration listings for work-life

Listing-based score, 0–10, across 1,242 comparable listings. Shaded area = the share scoring below this one.

Living in Hopewell

Median resident rent
$1,856/mo≈ 50% of gross pay
Residents’ average commute
30 min
State income tax
Up to 10.8%
Sources & methodology

Sources: U.S. Census ACS 2024 five-year.

Ratios use this listing’s gross annual pay. Not a cost-of-living guarantee.

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey logo

About Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey

Insurance
Newark, NJ
5,001-10,000 employees

Benefits & Perks

Comprehensive health benefits (Medical/Dental/Vision)
Retirement Plans
Generous PTO
Incentive Plans
Wellness Programs
Paid Volunteer Time Off
Tuition Reimbursement