Goodwill NYNJ logo
Goodwill NYNJ
New York, New York

Senior Mental Health Counselor

Counselor Top 25% in Mental Health CounselingFull-Time

Listed compensation

$55K - $65K

  • 80%better work-life than Mental Health Counseling peers
  • +80%Mental Health Counseling listings, last 30 days

The week · per this posting

Ask the employer about call expectations, weekend coverage and nights and shift pattern.

Posted 1mo ago

Job Description

Goodwill Greater New York and Northern New Jersey (GWNYNJ) believes that the power of work and sustainable fashion is how we unlock the good in our communities. For over 100 years, we have helped people get jobs, stay employed, and progress in careers across New York and Northern New Jersey.

We believe that diversity drives innovation and strengthens our workplace. We are committed to fostering our inclusive environment where all employees feel valued, respected, and empowered to contribute fully. We welcome applicants of all backgrounds, identities, experiences, and abilities.

PROS Senior Mental Health Counselor

Department: Behavioral Health Services Reports To: PROS Assistant Program Director FLSA Status: Exempt Location: NYC (Harlem)

Position Summary

The PROS Senior Counselor provides clinical and rehabilitative services within Goodwill Industries of Greater New York and Northern New Jersey, Inc.’s OMH-licensed Personalized Recovery Oriented Services (PROS) program. The Senior Mental Health Counselor delivers direct services to participants, supports individualized recovery planning, and supports leadership in promoting service quality, staff support, and recovery-oriented practice.

This position functions as a senior, experienced clinician who provides guidance to other counselors, supervises student interns, contributes to program operations, and supports compliance with NYS Office of Mental Health (OMH) PROS regulations, while advancing Goodwill’s mission to empower individuals to achieve independence and dignity through work.

Essential Duties and Responsibilities

· Provide direct PROS services to assigned participants in accordance with OMH PROS service definitions and recovery goals.

· Facilitate individual and group services focused on skill development, wellness self-management, community integration, employment readiness, and goal attainment.

· Manage caseload of 17-20 participants.

· Collaborate with participants to develop and implement individualized recovery plans that are person-centered, strength-based, and culturally responsive.

· Monitor participant progress and adjust service interventions as needed.

· Serve as a clinical resource and informal mentor to PROS counselors and support staff.

· Support consistent implementation of recovery-oriented, trauma-informed, and evidence-based practices.

· Assist with case conferencing, utilization discussions, and clinical problem-solving.

· Participate in treatment team meetings and interdisciplinary collaboration.

· Provide direct supervision to 2-4 student interns annually.

· Complete all clinical documentation accurately, thoroughly, and within required OMH and Medicaid timeframes; ensure documentation supports medical necessity, recovery goals, and service delivery standards.

· Contribute to maintaining a safe, inclusive, and recovery-focused program environment.

· Assist participants in accessing community-based resources that support recovery and independence.

Qualifications

· Master’s degree in Social Work, Psychology, Rehabilitation, or a related human services field required along with NYS professional licensure (LMSW, LCSW, LMHC, LMFT), Required.

· Minimum of 3 years of experience providing behavioral health or psychiatric rehabilitation services.

· Experience in licensed programs preferred; PROS experience preferred.

· Prior experience facilitating groups and working with individuals with serious mental illness preferred.

Knowledge, Skills, and Abilities

· Working knowledge of recovery-oriented and person-centered practice models.

· Familiarity with OMH PROS regulations and Medicaid documentation standards.

· Strong interpersonal, organizational, and communication skills.

· Ability to work collaboratively with multidisciplinary teams.

· Demonstrated commitment to Goodwill’s mission and value

Physical Demands & Work Environment

· Program-site based with regular interaction with participants and staff.

· May include periods of standing, walking, and facilitating groups.

· Occasional local travel for community activities or trainings.

What We Offer

  • Generous time-off policy to use when you need it.
  • Health, wellness, and financial resources to help you achieve your personal goals.
  • Robust health benefits including medical, dental, vision, parental leave, and company-sponsored life insurance.
  • Retirement matching programs and contributions.
  • Transit and commuter benefits.

#IND1

We believe in creating space for everyone to do their best work and have individual and collective impact. We believe in challenging the status quo and setting ambitious goals in the name of doing more good. We believe that being your best self and helping others do the same is how we bring our mission alive. Even if you don’t think you meet all the qualifications listed for the job, we would love to hear from you!

If you require a reasonable accommodation at any point in the application or interview process, or if you are unable to apply through our recruitment portal, please contact us at humanresources@goodwillny.org. We are happy to assist and ensure you have an equal opportunity to apply.

Key Responsibilities

The Senior Mental Health Counselor provides clinical and rehabilitative services to participants within a PROS program, including individualized recovery planning and group facilitation. The role also involves mentoring junior staff, supervising student interns, and ensuring compliance with OMH and Medicaid documentation standards.

Qualifications

Education
Professional certificate or licensure
Experience
2+ years of experience

Key Skills

Clinical counselingCase managementTrauma-informed careCrisis interventionMedicaid compliance

Work-Life Balance Analysis

WeekdayDoc's proprietary algorithm rates Senior Mental Health Counselor at Goodwill NYNJ a 7.2 out of 10 for work-life balance — classified as very good. This places the position in the top 25% in Mental Health Counseling — ranked against 632 active Mental Health Counseling listings on WeekdayDoc.

Counselor Career Context

In New York, the Mental Health Counseling weighted monthly median benchmark on WeekdayDoc is ~$70k (29 salary observations; 65 listings), vs ~$79k nationally (228 salary observations; 622 listings). Monthly aggregates cover 2026-01-01 through 2026-09-01; these are not the modal's selected comparable-job medians.

Of the 50 active Mental Health Counseling listings this role was benchmarked against, 38% are remote, 38% have no call, 62% require no weekends.

Mental Health Counseling pay on WeekdayDoc is up 4.9% vs. the prior quarter (through Aug 2026).

The cost-of-living index for New York is 107.9 (US average = 100; BEA Regional Price Parities (2024)), so the posted ~$60k midpoint carries the purchasing power of roughly $56k in an average-cost state. 64.6% of New York clinicians report burnout symptoms in WeekdayDoc's Burnout Index (2026-01 data).

Top Counselor Jobs

35 matches · ranked by pay

Salary Distribution35 jobs · 28 employers

7
<$75k
16
$75k-90k
7
$90k-105k
5
$105k-120k

Annual compensation range

Benefits & Perks25 jobs

401k / retirement match
76% this job
Sign-on bonus
40%
CME allowance
36%
Loan repayment
8%
PSLF eligible
8%

Share of similar jobs offering each benefit

#1

Licensed Mental Health Counselor

LifeStance Health · Kirkland, Washington

$90k-$115k
#2

Licensed Mental Health Counselor (LMHC)

LifeStance Health · Cranston, Rhode Island

$72k-$115k
#3

Mental Health Clinician (LCSW, LMFT, LPC) | $73.9K–$111.6K

$74k-$112k
#4

Licensed Mental Health Therapist (LMFT, LPCC, LPP, LCSW)

$100k-$110k
+ 33 more · ranked by pay

Work-life snapshot

median 6.0this job 7.2
Better work-life than 80% of Mental Health Counseling listings

Listing-based score, 0–10, across 632 comparable listings. Shaded area = the share scoring below this one.

  • On-site

Living in New York

Typical 3-bedroom home value
$876k≈ 15.9× annual pay
Typical market rent
$4,154/mo≈ 91% of gross pay
Residents’ average commute
40 min
State income tax
Up to 10.9%
Sources & methodology

Sources: Zillow home values (Aug 2026), Zillow market rents (Aug 2026), U.S. Census ACS 2024 five-year.

Ratios use this listing’s gross annual pay. Not a cost-of-living guarantee.

Goodwill NYNJ logo

About Goodwill NYNJ

Non-profit Organizations
Brooklyn, New York
201-500 employees

Benefits & Perks

Generous time-off policy
Health, wellness, and financial resources
Medical, dental, vision
Parental leave
Company-sponsored life insurance
Retirement matching programs
Transit and commuter benefits