Goodwill NYNJ logo
Goodwill NYNJ
New York, New York

Behavioral Health Counselor

Counselor / TherapistFull-Time

Listed compensation

$50k-$53k

The week · per this posting · weekdays assumed

Ask the employer about the work setting, call expectations, weekend coverage and time off.

Posted 1h ago · Verified live

Job Description

Goodwill Greater New York and Northern New Jersey (GWNYNJ) believes that the power of work and sustainable fashion is how we unlock the good in our communities. For over 100 years, we have helped people get jobs, stay employed, and progress in careers across New York and Northern New Jersey.

We believe that diversity drives innovation and strengthens our workplace. We are committed to fostering our inclusive environment where all employees feel valued, respected, and empowered to contribute fully. We welcome applicants of all backgrounds, identities, experiences, and abilities.

Location: Harlem, NY

General Purpose

  • The Behavioral Health Counselor is working with a PROS program to conduct individual and group services.
  • Personalized Recovery Oriented Services (PROS) is a comprehensive model that integrates rehabilitation, treatment, and support services for people with serious mental illness and possible other co-occurring disorders.
  • The Behavioral Health counselor works with PROS participants towards goals in different areas:
  • Living independently
  • Building natural supports
  • Finding and keeping a job
  • Reaching higher levels of education
  • Securing preferred housing

Improving Medication Management

This will be carried out as indicated by NYS OMH Part 512 Regulations and Medicaid requirements.

Essential Functions

Manage a caseload of up to 25 consumers, including case management, collateral contacts, referrals, vocational assistance, and other needs, to coordinate services.

Conduct required assessments including Wellness Recovery Action Plans, Psycho-socials, Psychiatric Rehabilitation, and Substance Use screenings and assessment.

Develop Individualized Recovery Plans (IRP) in collaboration with participants, on a bi-annual basis, or more often as necessary.

Maintain and update demographic, treatment and employment data in electronic health records (Foothold AWARDS, OMH CAIRS database, and NYESS).

Facilitate member access to community support services including medical, mental health, substance abuse, housing and entitlements.

Develop and facilitate approximately 6 -8 groups, according to protocol and curriculum, which will cover CRS, ORS, IR and Clinical Services as dictated.

Conduct individual counseling sessions to assist program participants with attainment of the life role goals specified in their IRPs.

Document consumers’ progress towards goals in monthly progress notes and determine the need for addition or subtraction of services offered to each participant on an ongoing basis.

Coordinate treatment including the sharing of Individual Recovery Plans and Progress Notes for participants who are co-enrolled with other agencies as necessary.

Provide services according to Evidence Based Practices including Wellness Self Management, Family Psychoeducation (CCFC), Medication Management, Co-occurring Disorders (IDDT), and Supported Employment (IPS).

Coordinate follow-up services once a participant is ready for discharge from the program.

Act as a member of an interdisciplinary treatment team, including participation in weekly administrative, clinical and utilization review meetings.

Assume overall responsibility for maintenance of client records, including timely documentation of services in Electronic Health Record (AWARDS), as required by Medicaid and the Office of Mental Health.

Develop and maintain collateral relationships with consumers’ other providers and family as clinically indicated

  • Carry a 24-hour support cell phone in rotation with the clinical team.
  • Other duties as assigned.
  • Qualifications/Basic Job Requirements:.

A minimum of a Bachelor’s Degree in Psychology, Social Work, Human Development and related field, 3+ years of experience working with adults with mental illness and/or families dealing with mental illness. Masters Degree preferred.

Team-based skills are essential.

Previous experience working with individuals with psychiatric/co-occurring disorders preferred. Knowledge of running groups preferred.

Computer skills and knowledge of service documentation required.

Criminal background check and fingerprinting required; screening for the GSA, OIG and OMIG lists of persons disallowed from working in Medicaid funded programs

What We Offer

  • Generous time-off policy to use when you need it.
  • Health, wellness, and financial resources to help you achieve your personal goals.
  • Robust health benefits, including medical, dental, vision, parental leave, and company-sponsored life insurance.
  • Retirement matching programs and contributions.
  • Transit and commuter benefits.

We believe in creating space for everyone to do their best work and have individual and collective impact. We believe in challenging the status quo and setting ambitious goals in the name of doing more good. We believe that being your best self and helping others do the same is how we bring our mission alive. Even if you don’t think you meet all the qualifications listed for the job, we would love to hear from you!

If you require a reasonable accommodation at any point in the application or interview process, or if you are unable to apply through our recruitment portal, please contact us at humanresources@goodwillny.org. We are happy to assist and ensure you have an equal opportunity to apply.

Key Responsibilities

The Behavioral Health Counselor manages a caseload of up to 25 consumers, providing case management, individual counseling, and group facilitation within a PROS program. They are responsible for conducting assessments, developing recovery plans, and maintaining accurate clinical documentation in electronic health records.

Requirements

A minimum of a Bachelor’s degree in Psychology, Social Work, or a related field is required, with a Master's degree preferred. Candidates must have at least 3 years of experience working with adults with mental illness and possess strong team-based and documentation skills.

Qualifications

Education
Master's degree (postgraduate degree)
Experience
2+ years of experience

Key Skills

Crisis interventionPsychosocial assessmentTreatment planningSubstance use screeningInterdisciplinary collaborationMental health supportCommunity resource coordination

Behavioral Health — Counselor Career Context

The cost-of-living index for New York is 107.9 (US average = 100; BEA Regional Price Parities (2024)), so the posted ~$52k midpoint carries the purchasing power of roughly $48k in an average-cost state. 64.6% of New York clinicians report burnout symptoms in WeekdayDoc's Burnout Index (2026-01 data).

Of the 50 active Behavioral Health listings this role was benchmarked against, 58% are remote, 26% have no call, 56% require no weekends.

What does the Behavioral Health market look like in New York?
MeasureThis jobMarket
Listed pay$50k–$53kBehavioral Health median $73k (middle half $67k–$82k)40 comparable listings, Nov 2026
Cost-of-living adjusted pay~$48k in purchasing powerNew York index 107.9 (US = 100)BEA Regional Price Parities (2024)
Behavioral Health listings in New York37 active344 nationallylive on WeekdayDoc, Nov 2026
Work settingon-sitepeers: 58% remote · 26% no call · 56% no weekends50 benchmarked listings
Sign-on & loan repaymentnot statedNew York Counselor listings: 12% state a sign-on bonus (median $5k) · 10% offer loan repayment799 active listings, Nov 2026
New Behavioral Health listings858 in the last 30 days562 the 30 days before (+53%)U.S., first seen on WeekdayDoc, Nov 2026
Behavioral Health pay trend−2.2% vs prior quarter—through Oct 2026
Sources: WeekdayDoc live listing index, BEA Regional Price Parities (2024); as of Nov 2026. Same values as the Weekday Verdict and Market Insights on this page.

Top Counselor Jobs

50 matches · ranked by pay

Salary Distribution

50 jobs · 35 employers
22
<$85k
20
$85k-100k
1
$100k
7
$115k-130k

Annual compensation range

Benefits & Perks

35 jobs
401k / retirement match
91% this job
Sign-on bonus
51%
CME allowance
40%
Loan repayment
14%
PSLF eligible
11%

Share of similar jobs offering each benefit

#1

Licensed Clinical Mental Health Therapist - LICSW - LPCC - LMFT

LifeStance Health · Saint Louis Park, Minnesota

$74k-$126k
#2

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist (LMFT, LPC, LCSW)

LifeStance Health · Brookfield, Wisconsin

$92k-$125k
#3

Mental Health Therapist - Portland

$90k-$123k
#4

Licensed Clinical Professional Counselor (LCPC)

$115k-$120k
+ 48 more · ranked by pay

Work-life snapshot

median 2.8this job 1.5
Below most Behavioral Health (Counseling) listings for work-life

Listing-based score, 0–10, across 340 comparable listings. Shaded area = the share scoring below this one.

Goodwill NYNJ logo

About Goodwill NYNJ

Non-profit Organizations
Brooklyn, New York
201-500 employees

Benefits & Perks

Generous time-off policy
Health, wellness, and financial resources
Medical, dental, vision, parental leave, company-sponsored life insurance
Retirement matching programs and contributions
Transit and commuter benefits

Living in New York

Typical 3-bedroom home value
$875k≈ 17.5× annual pay
Typical market rent
$4,089/mo≈ 98% of gross pay
Residents’ average commute
40 min
State income tax
Up to 10.9%
Sources & methodology

Sources: Zillow home values (Sep 2026), Zillow market rents (Sep 2026), U.S. Census ACS 2024 five-year.

Ratios use this listing’s gross annual pay. Not a cost-of-living guarantee.